Welcome to Lobster Roll Restaurant
-
1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY 11930 Hotline: (631) 267-3740
Welcome to the Lobster Roll Restaurant, an iconic dining destination located at 1980 Montauk Hwy, Amagansett, NY. This charming spot is known for its American seafood fare, offering a feast of coastal flavors that will transport your taste buds straight to the sun-soaked shores of New England. As you step inside, you're immediately greeted by a nautical vibe that harmonizes perfectly with the fresh seafood you'll be indulging in.
- Signature Dishes: The stars of the menu are undeniably the lobster rolls—both hot and cold varieties that feature generous, succulent chunks of lobster served in a buttery New England-style roll. Patrons rave about the hot lobster roll, highlighting the rich flavors and tender textures that make it a must-try for any seafood lover.
- Hearty Appetizers: Start your meal with their delicious Seafood Nachos or comforting Homemade Lobster Bisque, both of which promise to whet your appetite. The chowders, particularly the creamy New England version, also enjoy a well-deserved reputation among locals and visitors alike.
- Outdoor Dining: With the option of sitting on the patio, your dining experience is further enriched by the fresh air and lively atmosphere. The rustic picnic table aesthetic enhances the fun, casual vibe that guests appreciate, making it ideal for a relaxed meal with friends or family.
As you savor your meal, you’ll notice many guests returning for that perfect sip of a Baileys Banana Colada, which has become a favorite for pairing with the savory dishes. Feedback from loyal customers consistently highlights the friendly service, the vibrant ambiance, and the unpretentious yet delicious seafood that draws them back time and again.
While some might wish for more vegetarian options, the **Lobster Roll Restaurant** still serves up classic sides and desserts, including their decadent chocolate cake, ensuring there’s a little something for everyone. Whether you’re after a quick bite on vacation or a leisurely lunch under the arbor, this place captures the essence of coastal dining with a local touch.
If seafood is your passion, then the Lobster Roll Restaurant should undoubtedly rank high on your must-visit list. Bring your appetite and prepare to indulge in a seafood experience that perfectly marries quality with the inviting charm of the Hamptons.
Contact: (631) 267-3740
This is my boyfriend's favorite restaurant of all time. He is obsessed with the lobster roll and baileys banana coolada (I'm not sure if that's the name because he always calls the drink a BBC). Drinks are always spot on and the patio is the best place to enjoy the summer weather. I'm not exaggerating when I say we go 5 times a year. The only feedback I have is that the vegetarian options are a little limited- I wish there was more than just a veggie burger- but the fries are classic and the vibe of the place is killer.
Best lobster roll I've had in NY. Highly recommend the hot lobster roll and lobster bisque. The hot lobster roll comes with a generous amount of lobster in a dish, with a buttered New England style roll. Both soups are good, but the lobster bisque is better than the clam chowder. Indoor and outdoor seating that all feels picnic table-like. Patio is great on a warm day.
Stopped in with the gals for a late lunch and cocktail. This is a beachy, fun, touristy place that serves the usual oceanside fare. Lots of fried food options and fun cocktails. We sat outside under the arbor in back which is a neat atmosphere but a little buggy. The food is good, not great, but I think you go here for the fun of it. Servers are friendly and helpful looking to turn tables but not so much that you feel rushed.
This is a cute spot right on the highway where you can stop easily. Keep an eye out or you'll miss it! The food is good; just get the lobster roll. They're so fresh and the lobster chunks are huge. You may think it's pricey, but it's on par with the rest of town. You can sit outside on nice days and it's worth waiting for a table.
Outdoor seating last night. The warm and cold lobster rolls are still 5 stars. Didn't have the clam strips this time but I did order the dozen clams. The lobster bisque was so good. I had to take another back home for later tonight.
Very cute spot right on the side of sunrise and easy to drive right past. Yes it is called lunch. Apparently they have some proprietary mayo that goes into their lobster roll which will run you $37 (menu says MP). Ordered the lobster salad so lobster on a bed of greens with coleslaw and some dressing. Lobster roll portion it self was fair and basically what you would expect. Mayo was nothing fancy Clams on half shell - even though I asked for oysters they made a whoopsie but all good. Yummy fresh and delicious but tiny itty bitty little necks Seafood nachos - seafood chili over nachos. Sounds bit crazy, pretty darn yummy but lacking salt Clam chowder New England- what you would expect but also lacking in salt Overall a nice place. Prices are reasonable for the area. Food is good, nothing really over the top amazing. Staff are friendly and service is quick
Delicious hot and cold lobster rolls, insanely good chocolate cake, charming outdoor dining under a grove, an iconic staple in the Hamptons. A must-stop when you're here. Only good things. 5 stars!!!
Stopped here on our first day of vacation. It was a rainy Sunday so it might have been why it was so easy to get a table but service was quick, friendly, and efficient. Prices are reasonable for a beach location and the food is fantastic. Possibly the best lobster roll I have ever had. Also if you have ever seen the show the Affair a lot of it is set here they just gave it a different name which made it extra fun to look around and see. Definitely recommend!
Finally got to come for a lobster roll here. Have passed it a bunch of times off season when they're closed. We sat inside. The decor is simple and the seating is a wooden booth/bench style. Our waitress was sweet and attentive. My husband ordered the lobster bisque which was probably one of the best I've ever tasted. Our toddler loved it too. We both got the hot lobster roll which came with a generous portion of lobster that you put into roll yourself, coleslaw, and fries. It was very good, though some lobster pieces were chewy. We will be back!